Prevention of Future Death Reports: Threshold, Purpose and Proper Limits


Categories:

Introduction

Few aspects of an inquest attract as much attention, or as much misunderstanding, as a Prevention of Future Death report (often shortened to a “PFD Report”).

  • For families, a PFD Report can represent meaningful change and help to ensure more families don’t go through anything similar.
  • For public bodies, it can carry reputational and regulatory consequences and attract unwelcome public scrutiny.
  • For legal practitioners, it requires disciplined and evidence-based submissions that are focused on the law.

The statutory foundation lies in Schedule 5 paragraph 7 of the Coroners and Justice Act 2009 and Regulations 28 and 29 of the Coroners (Investigations) Regulations 2013. (As such, PFD Reports are also sometimes called “Regulation 28 Reports”. Both terms refer to reports made under the same statutory framework.)

Understanding the criteria for making a PFD Report is essential.


The Statutory Test

Schedule 5 paragraph 7 of the Coroners and Justice Act 2009 states:

(7) (1) Where —

(a) a senior coroner has been conducting an investigation under this Part into a person’s death,

(b) anything revealed by the investigation gives rise to a concern that circumstances creating a risk of other deaths will occur, or will continue to exist, in the future, and

(c) In the coroner’s opinion, action should be taken to prevent the occurrence or continuation of such circumstances, or to eliminate or reduce the risk of death created by such circumstances,

the coroner must report the matter to a person who the coroner believes may have power to take such action.

[Bold emphasis added]

So a Coroner must make a report where:

  • An investigation gives rise to a concern that circumstances creating a risk of other deaths will occur, or continue to exist; and
  • In the Coroner’s opinion, action should be taken to prevent the occurrence or continuation of such circumstances.

The power is always preventative – never punitive.

Whether the statutory conditions are satisfied is a matter for the Coroner’s judicial assessment. However, once those conditions are met, the duty to report is mandatory. A PFD Report is not simply an optional recommendation which the Coroner may choose to make or withhold.


Causation and Evidential Foundation

A PFD Report cannot be made merely because a failing is identified.

The concern must arise from something revealed during the investigation and must relate to a risk of future death.

The Coroner’s concern must have a sufficient foundation in the evidence or information revealed during the investigation

This ensures that PFD reports maintain their statutory purpose: prevention, not public inquiry or blame.

So:

  • A concern need not relate to a matter which caused or contributed to the death under investigation.
    • For example, an inquest into a workplace death might reveal a separate safety practice creating a risk of future fatalities. If that practice has been sufficiently explored during the investigation, it may properly form the subject of a PFD Report, notwithstanding that it did not contribute to the death being investigated.
  • However, an incidental reference to an unrelated concern, which has not been adequately examined, will not necessarily provide a sufficient evidential foundation for a report.
  • It must relate to a risk of death, not merely harm.
    • This is a specific statutory requirement and a relatively high threshold. If solely further harm (not further death) is anticipated, a PFD Report is not appropriate.
  • It must not amount to a roving policy review or a further opportunity to gather evidence.
    • PFD Reports are not used to conduct a public inquiry.

The Current Position and Remedial Action

The Coroner must consider the position at the time the need for a PFD Report is assessed, ordinarily at the conclusion of the inquest.

Where an organisation has already implemented effective measures addressing the relevant risk, the Coroner may conclude that further action is unnecessary and that the statutory duty to report does not arise.

However, the fact that changes have been proposed, or that an organisation has undertaken to implement them, does not automatically resolve the concern.

The Coroner must consider the nature of the proposed measures, the evidence supporting their effectiveness and whether there remains a risk of future deaths requiring action.

The distinction is important. A PFD Report is concerned with preventing future deaths, rather than formally recording criticism of historic failings.


Article 2 Inquests and PFD Reports

The Revised Chief Coroner’s Guidance No. 5: Reports to Prevent Future Deaths states at §46:

In an Article 2 inquest the PFD may complete the state’s duty to inquire fully … but a PFD is not mandatory simply because an inquest is an Article 2 inquest.

The duty to make a PFD Report therefore remains governed by the statutory test, irrespective of whether the enhanced investigative obligation under Article 2 applies.

A Coroner must make a report where:

  • Something revealed by the investigation gives rise to a concern that circumstances creating a risk of other deaths will occur, or continue to exist, in the future; and
  • In the Coroner’s opinion, action should be taken to prevent those circumstances occurring or continuing, or to eliminate or reduce the risk of death they create.

The report must be directed to a person whom the Coroner believes may have the power to take such action.


Making Submissions

Whether a PFD Report is required is ultimately a matter for the Coroner.

Although the Coroner is not obliged to invite submissions from Interested Persons in every case, representations may assist in identifying whether the statutory conditions are satisfied.

Submissions should remain focused upon the evidence, the continuing risk of future death and the action which may be necessary to address that risk.

To put it another way, the Coroner might ask:

  1. What concerning circumstances have been revealed?
  2. How it creates a risk of future death?
  3. Why preventative action remains necessary?

What Happens After a PFD Report?

A PFD Report is sent to the person or organisation whom the Coroner believes may have the power to take appropriate action.

The recipient must ordinarily respond within 56 days, although the Coroner may extend that period.

The response must explain what action has been taken or is proposed, together with the relevant timetable, or explain why no action is proposed.

Reports and responses may subsequently be published by the Chief Coroner, enabling the concerns and proposed measures to be scrutinised publicly.

However, the Coroner does not have a general power to compel the recipient to implement particular remedial measures. The statutory mechanism is directed towards identifying concerns and requiring a response, rather than enforcing a prescribed solution.


Conclusion

A PFD report is a powerful statutory mechanism. But it is confined to:

  • Evidence arising from the investigation
  • Risks of future death
  • Preventative, not punitive, purpose

Careful forensic framing often determines the outcome.


Advice on Prevention of Future Death Reports

If you are seeking to invite a PFD Report, clear and disciplined submissions are essential. If you would like to discuss PFD reports or systemic risk findings in an inquest, please contact me here.