Introduction
You may have been told that your loved one’s inquest “engages Article 2”. This refers to the right to life under the European Convention on Human Rights.
In certain circumstances, Article 2 requires the state to undertake a more extensive investigation into a death. This is commonly described as the enhanced investigative obligation.
However, Article 2 does not apply to every death involving a hospital, public authority or other state organisation. Whether the enhanced obligation arises depends upon the circumstances of the death and the legal duties engaged.
What Is Article 2?
Article 2 of the European Convention on Human Rights protects the right to life.
It imposes obligations upon the state, including duties to establish appropriate systems for protecting life and, in certain circumstances, to take reasonable steps to protect individuals from known risks.
Article 2 also imposes investigative obligations where a person has died in circumstances which engage the relevant legal requirements.
Some deaths, including particular deaths in state custody, engage the enhanced investigative obligation because of the circumstances in which they occur. In other cases, it may arise where there is an arguable breach of the state’s substantive obligations under Article 2.
However, the involvement of a public authority does not automatically mean that the enhanced investigative obligation applies.
For example, an allegation that medical treatment was negligent will not ordinarily be sufficient by itself. The Supreme Court considered this distinction in R (Maguire) v HM Senior Coroner for Blackpool and Fylde [2023] UKSC 20.
How Does It Change the Inquest?
Every inquest must establish who died and how, when and where the deceased came by their death.
Where the enhanced investigative obligation under Article 2 applies, the inquest must also establish in what circumstances the deceased came by their death.
This may require a broader examination of the events leading to the death, including relevant decisions, omissions, policies and systems.
In practice, an Article 2 inquest may involve:
- A wider investigation into the circumstances of the death;
- Additional documentary evidence;
- Evidence from more witnesses, potentially including senior decision-makers;
- Examination of relevant policies, procedures and organisational arrangements; and
- More detailed factual findings or a narrative conclusion.
The precise scope will depend upon the circumstances of the individual case.
Article 2 does not automatically require an inquest to be heard with a jury. Whether a jury is required is a separate question governed principally by section 7 of the Coroners and Justice Act 2009.
Does Article 2 Mean Someone Is to Blame?
No. The engagement of Article 2 does not mean that a public authority has acted unlawfully or that any person is responsible for the death.
The purpose of the inquest remains to establish the relevant facts.
The Coroner or jury may identify failures in care, shortcomings in procedures or omissions which contributed to the death.
However, an inquest cannot determine criminal liability on the part of a named person or civil liability.
There is therefore an important distinction between identifying factual failings and making a formal determination of legal liability.
Why Legal Advice Can Be Important
Article 2 cases are often more complex. There may involve:
- Large volumes of disclosure
- Multiple public bodies, likely all represented by lawyers
- Complicated medical, technical or policy evidence
Early legal advice can help ensure that the scope of the inquest is properly defined and that important issues are not overlooked.
What Happens Next?
Whether Article 2 applies will often be considered at a Pre-Inquest Review
The Coroner may invite submissions from Interested Persons about the circumstances of the death, the relevant legal obligations and the appropriate scope of the investigation.
The position may also change as further evidence becomes available.
A family may consider that the enhanced investigative obligation should apply, particularly where concerns arise about the conduct of public authorities. However, Article 2 engagement must be determined by reference to the applicable legal principles and the evidence, rather than the preference of any particular Interested Person.
Early legal advice may assist in identifying the relevant issues and ensuring that appropriate submissions are made before the scope of the investigation is finalised.